- 2 cups powdered Swerve
- 1 cup cocoa (American-process preferred)
- 2 1/2 cups powdered fat free milk
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 2 teaspoons cornstarch or tapioca starch
- 1 pinch cayenne pepper, or more to taste, if desired
- Hot water
I absolutely adore hot chocolate. I like it with whipped cream. I like it with marshmallows. I like it with booze.
My sister-in-law, Nancy, makes great hot cocoa and gives it away at Christmas. Well, we didn’t see her last year and I was totally craving some hot cocoa and I didn’t want to buy some from the store, so I figured I’d make my own recipe. I was looking for inspiration and came across a recipe from Alton Brown. It looked great, but I knew I had to make it healthier, so I started testing recipes using Swerve all-natural zero-calorie sweetener and now I have a recipe that rivals Nancy’s, but doesn’t wreak havoc on your waistline (or keep you up at night!)
We don’t have a video of this recipe right now, but check out our channel at http://www.youtube.com/user/Thindulge and see videos of other recipes from this blog. If you have any requests, please let us know!
You can also “like” us on Facebook here, follow us on Twitter @thindulge and Pinterest here.
DIRECTIONS
Combine all ingredients in a mixing bowl and incorporate evenly. In a small pot, heat water to just under boiling
Fill your mug 1/3 to 1/2 full with the mixture, depending on how strong you like your cooca. Pour in hot water. Stir to combine. Seal the rest in an airtight container, keeps indefinitely in the pantry. This also works great with warm milk.
Here’s the skinny:
First, I used Swerve instead of powdered sugar, saving over 200 grams of sugar and almost 1000 calories out of the batch.
Also, I used nonfat dry milk instead of whole dry milk, saving another 1000 calories and 75 grams of fat, in addition to over 200mg of cholesterol
CALORIES SAVED: 1984
FAT SAVED: 75g
SATURATED FAT SAVED: 42g
SUGAR SAVED: 307g
CHOLESTEROL SAVED: 237mg





Hi Anthony! I love hot cocoa and have it every night, though I cheat big time by just mixing my (mostly all natural) chocolate whey protein powder with some water or black tea and then heating that up.
I will try this recipe sometime, or at least get some cayenne pepper to try!
I’m personally not so concerned about calories as I am about chemically altered products, so I’d normally use honey or agave to sweeten drinks. I hadn’t heard of Swerve before but looked it up and it looks like a healthy sugar substitute, because it’s erythritol which can occur naturally in some fruits and fermented foods. Supposedly, it’s mass-produced by fermenting natural sugars found in corn. If you know of a brand out there that goes the extra mile and uses non-GMO corn, let me know! Thanks for this and other great recipes!
I thought you’d like Swerve.
I’ll ask them if they use non-GMO corn or not… I don’t know for sure. And thanks for your support! I knew there was a reason I liked you – a fellow hot cocoa fan
Just making my way through all the sites that are participating in Carolyn’s World Diabetes Day awareness campaign & wanted to say hello & thx (I’m a type 2, btw)
Hi CJ! Great to meet you! Glad to be participating and helping out!
I must try this recipe. Thanks!
Great! My pleasure! Let me know how it turns out!
Hi! Just looking around at all the fabulous diabetes awareness day recipes. Do you have a dairy free option for this by any chance? Something lactose intolerant friendly?
Sure! I used dry milk and water, but if you want to skip the dry milk and heat up your favorite unsweetened non-dairy milk, that would be great! You’ll just have to add cocoa mix as needed to get the right flavor. For an extra dose of chocolate, you can use an unsweetened chocolate non-dairy milk like almond milk. That sounds yummy – I may have to try that myself!
Do you know how many servings this makes? I am so excited to see a mix for hot chocolate that I can drink as well!
It makes over 5 cups of dry mix, but the number of servings depends on how strong you make it. If you used equal parts mix and water, that would get you about 11 cups of yummy hot chocolate! It’s a lot, so I keep mine in a airtight containter in my pantry and break it out when I’m in the mood for some hot cocoa.
Awesome, thanks!
While eating lower-carb, hot chocolate has been my main downfall. Unfortunately I enjoy it too often made with the packaged artificially sweetened stuff… Swiss Miss anyone? It’s not even that good, darn it. Would love to try this!
It’s my downfall too! I was spoiled by my sister-in-law and just couldn’t go back to Swiss Miss again. I hope you like this as much as I do! I always have a container of this stuff in my pantry!
My daughter adores hot chocolate as well. I think I just may put together a hot chocolate mix and sub Swerve! I’ll bet she will never noticE!!!
I bet she will – I can’t tell the difference and I love sugar!
What a great way to enjoy hot cocoa! Thanks for sharing.
My pleasure! Let me know how it turns out!
I’m visiting all the sites participating in the Diabetes awareness event to say thank you for doing this. I’ve had gestational diabetes and my sister is a Type I, so I’m happy someone like Carolyn is trying to get the word out about low-carb eating. And, um . . . was there supposed to be a Swerve giveaway here?
Thanks Catherine! Glad to help! My dad has diabetes as well. And there was a miscommunication about the Swerve giveaway…
Thanks for taking part in my WDD Initiative! I am trying to post this on my Facebook page, but the link won’t come up for some reason. Bear with me!
It was my pleasure! Glad to help! It looks like it was a huge success – thank you for doing this!